A San Francisco company is being sued in a San Francisco courthouse under California law, and California ChatGPT users have been given subclasses of their own. The class action, Vredenburgh v. OpenAI OpCo, LLC, No. 3:26-cv-10527, was filed September 16, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. It alleges that OpenAI sent real ChatGPT conversations to contractors at an outside staffing firm, who read and graded them under a program code-named “Project Lily,” without telling users where they would look. OpenAI has not yet responded, and the allegations are unproven.
Why the Case Is So Californian
Seven of the complaint’s eight claims are built on California law: the Unfair Competition Law, the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, the False Advertising Law, fraudulent omission, intrusion upon seclusion, the privacy right in the California Constitution and the California Consumer Privacy Act. The eighth, unjust enrichment, is pleaded alongside them.
That is not unusual for a tech case filed here. California’s consumer statutes are among the broadest in the country, and a company headquartered in the state is an easy fit for them. It is the same pattern we described in why health website privacy claims keep landing in California.
Two California-specific pieces stand out:
- A constitutional privacy right. California voters added privacy to the list of inalienable rights in Article I, Section 1 of the state constitution in 1972, and it applies to private companies as well as the government. Most states have nothing comparable.
- The CCPA. The California Consumer Privacy Act gives residents a private right to sue in limited circumstances, with statutory damages of $100 to $750 per consumer per incident, now adjusted for inflation. The complaint uses it to allege OpenAI shared personal information for an undisclosed purpose without reasonable safeguards. Whether that claim fits the statute, which is written around security failures, is likely to be one of the first issues argued.
Who Is in the California Subclasses
The proposed nationwide class covers everyone in the United States who used ChatGPT during the limitations period, free or paid. Beneath it the complaint proposes a California subclass of the state’s ChatGPT users and a California subscriber subclass of Californians who paid for ChatGPT Plus, Pro or another consumer plan. A third subclass covers paying subscribers nationwide. Users of ChatGPT Enterprise, Business, Team and Edu accounts are excluded, as are API customers. That carve-out touches plenty of Californians: students and staff on university Edu seats and Bay Area employees on company plans are outside the class for those accounts, though not for their personal ones.
What the Complaint Says Happened
The complaint draws on a 404 Media investigation published September 14. It says contractors recruited through the staffing firm Crossing Hurdles, in roles advertised as “AI data reviewer” and “chatbot evaluator,” were shown real user prompts, often whole conversations. They summarized what the user wanted, read four ChatGPT responses, scored each from one to seven and wrote a rationale that fed back into model development. An automated “Privacy Filter” runs first, but the complaint says OpenAI’s own documentation calls it a redaction aid, not a guarantee.
OpenAI does disclose human access in one place: a Help Center FAQ saying “trusted service providers” may access content “to improve model performance (unless you have opted out).” The complaint says that answer sits among about 45 nested help articles, while the Privacy Policy’s list of eleven kinds of outside data recipients includes no human-review vendor.
The Court Calendar
- September 21, 2026 — OpenAI served.
- October 13, 2026 — OpenAI’s response to the complaint due.
- Mid-October — the 30-day window on the plaintiffs’ September 16 CLRA demand letter closes; they say they will add damages to that claim if OpenAI does not respond.
- December 11, 2026 — joint case management statement due.
- December 18, 2026 — first case management conference before Magistrate Judge Alex G. Tse at the San Francisco courthouse.
A magistrate judge can preside over the whole case only if every party consents; otherwise it will be reassigned to a district judge in the same court.
📨 Get Free California Guides Alerts
Free · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
What Californians Can Do Now
There is nothing to file: no settlement, no claim form, no certified class. Users who want to limit how their chats are used going forward can review the “Improve the model for everyone” setting in ChatGPT’s data controls. It follows the San Jose court opened claims in Apple’s $250 million Siri settlement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where was the OpenAI ChatGPT human-review lawsuit filed?
In the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in San Francisco, on September 16, 2026. The case is Vredenburgh v. OpenAI OpCo, LLC, No. 3:26-cv-10527-AGT, assigned to Magistrate Judge Alex G. Tse.
Do California ChatGPT users have a separate subclass?
Yes, as proposed. The complaint includes a California subclass of ChatGPT users and a California subscriber subclass for Californians who paid for a consumer plan, in addition to the nationwide class. No class has been certified.
What California laws does the lawsuit use?
The Unfair Competition Law, the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, the False Advertising Law, the California Consumer Privacy Act and the privacy right in the California Constitution, along with fraudulent omission, intrusion upon seclusion and unjust enrichment.
Is there money for Californians from this case?
Not now. The case is at the complaint stage with no settlement and no claim process. OpenAI’s response is due October 13, 2026.
Sources
- Class Action Complaint, Vredenburgh v. OpenAI OpCo, LLC, No. 3:26-cv-10527-AGT (N.D. Cal., filed September 16, 2026).
- Court docket on CourtListener: service on September 21, 2026, the October 13 response deadline and the case management schedule.
- 404 Media, “Inside Project Lily: The Humans Reading Your ChatGPT Chats” (September 14, 2026), the reporting the complaint relies on.
- OpenAI Help Center, “Data Usage for Consumer Services FAQ”; OpenAI Privacy Policy and “How your data is used to improve model performance”.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. California News Now is not a law firm and is not affiliated with OpenAI or any party to the case. Everything described here is an allegation in a complaint: OpenAI has not yet responded in court, no class has been certified and no court has decided the merits. There is no settlement and nothing to claim. Anyone asking for a fee to “join” this case is not part of it.